I dearly love them both, Port Charlotte probably edges it for me, but I always have a bottle of Talisker 10 and have fond memories of the distillery and the isle of Skye. Get both, you owe it to yourself. I mean you are awesome and absolutely crushing it 😎
+1 for the PC10
I would go for PC
Port Charlotte
I'm gonna stan Bruichladdich every day.
I bought a bottle of PC 10 and it became one of my favorites instantly. So that’s my vote.
I’d get the PC only because it’s much harder to find where I live. But both you won’t go wrong either way.
Port Charlotte easy choice
Port Charlotte by a lot.
PC10, if Talisker 10 was also 50% abv then it may be a fair competition but PC10 is a bargain at T10 prices
PC 10. I love the Talisker, but if I saw Port Charlotte cheap - and I'm assuming that's what you mean - then I'd jump at it.
Buy the PC! At least where I live, the pc is often twice the price of talisker, and unlike talisker, is practically never put on sale. 🙂
I went with the PC, just couldn’t say no to the heavy peat.
I dearly love them both, Port Charlotte probably edges it for me, but I always have a bottle of Talisker 10 and have fond memories of the distillery and the isle of Skye. Get both, you owe it to yourself. I mean you are awesome and absolutely crushing it 😎
You make a good argument!
The only correct answer is both!
Both are amazing whiskies. Can't go wrong. Talisker is medium smoke and PS is heavy smoke. To which I say, porque no los dos?
You cannot choose wrong, but if I could only take one, it’s the Port Charlotte 10. Both are great.
PC10 any day of the week
I'm in the Talisker camp but I wouldn't say no to Port Charlotte.
They’re very different, and both excellent. I’d probably go Talisker but there’s no wrong answer.
Both are great! You need to try both honestly. I’m partial to talisker. It’s my favorite
PC10 all freaking day.
Pc10